This review is from: Joy (Amazon MP3 Exclusive Version) (MP3 Download) Don't normally leave reviews, but it was sad to see a single 1 star review for this album from a disappointed fan. As with the last couple of studio releases from Phish, Joy requires a) some interest in Phish and what they're doing and b) an open mind with regards to how the new stuff sounds vs. the old stuff.

I can't see this album being a commercial success, though its not for lack of trying. The first two tracks are clear commercial/radio shots. They're not bad, but I'd be surprised if they gained much mainstream appreciation. Diehard Phish fans will probably find them flat. Backwards Down the Number Line does catch on you after a few listens. The first minute of the song leaves a bad first impression, but by the end of it I'm wishing it would go on a bit longer. The inclusion of a nice live version of it on Track 11 is wise, as it shows the song can lead to a relatively interesting jam.

That said, there are some nice Phish nuggets here that open-minded Phans should appreciate: Sugar Shack is a fun and funky number - give it two listens before you judge. Ocelot has potential for a real nice live jam; I sense the studio isn't doing this song justice. Light starts out with a great electronic/instrumental jam that I look forward to hearing more improvisation upon. And, of course, Time Turns Elastic is a nice long exploration that will become a major 2nd Set contribution for shows to come.

Is it as good as Junta? Of course not. No band in history has ever put out work with he energy and creativity they started with 20+ years ago. That doesn't mean that something a third as good isn't worth creating. So give it a chance. For a band of this longevity, this is a solid effort.